Q: How did our native Thanksgiving bird get named for a country at the crossroads of Europe and Asia?
A: Yes, turkey, the main event at Thanksgiving dinners in the US, is native to the Americas.
The big bird came to the attention of Europeans in 1518 when the Spanish conquistador Juan de Grijalva encountered it in Mexico. The following year, Hernán Cortés found turkeys being domesticated by the Aztecs.
Knowing a good thing when they saw it, the Spanish soon transplanted the turkey (Meleagris gallopavo) to Europe.
(Columbus may have come across the bird in Honduras in 1502 on his fourth voyage, but it’s unclear whether the fowl that he referred to as gallina de la tierra, or land hen, was actually a turkey.)
But why, you ask, is the bird called a “turkey”? The reason is that Europeans confused it with the guinea fowl, an African species that was very briefly referred to as a “turkey” because it was thought to have been imported into Europe by way of Turkey.
The word “turkey” first began showing up in English as the name of the bird in the mid-16th century, according to the Oxford English Dictionary.
For example, Thomas Tusser’s book Fiue Hundreth Points of Good Husbandry Vnited to as Many of Good Huswiferie (1573) suggested that the Christmas table should include “shred pies of the best … & Turkey wel drest.”
The turkey is a noble bird, and in 19th-century North America the term “turkey” was often used figuratively in colloquial expressions that were generally positive.
For instance, to “talk turkey,” an expression first recorded in 1824, means to speak openly or frankly.
But pejorative uses of “turkey” eventually crept in.
In the 1920s, “turkey” came to be used as slang for an inferior theatrical or movie production. In other words, a flop.
The OED’s first example is from the American magazine Vanity Fair in 1927: “ ‘A turkey’ is a third rate production.”
The slang expression was soon extended to other kinds of failures and disappointments.
This example comes from James M. Cain’s novel Mildred Pierce (1943): “The beach … was studded with rocks and was therefore unsuitable to swimming. For all ordinary purposes it was simply a turkey.”
Later, in the early 1950s, “turkey” became a slang word for a stupid or inept person.
Incidentally, in case you’re wondering why the leg of a turkey or chicken is called the “drumstick,” check out a blog post we wrote in 2012.
No matter which part of the turkey you prefer, we hope that you and all our other readers will enjoy Thanksgiving dinner with your families tomorrow, a holiday that’s often referred to as “Turkey Day.”
The expression was first recorded, the OED says, in the Nov. 23, 1870, issue of the Hartford Courant: “To-morrow is turkey day, gobbler’s day, or the day when the gobbler is gobbled.”
Help support the Grammarphobia Blog with your donation.
And check out our books about the English language.